top of page

Part 1: The Day Nobody Listened

21 minutes ago
6 min read


How government stopped serving "we the people"


"Leadership is—and will always be—about people."™ I have said that sentence from a lot of stages, usually to rooms full of executives, managers, and team leaders. This series is about a bigger room. It is about the people we elect, the companies we buy from, the screens we stare at, and finally the people we sit across from at the holiday table.


Over the past 26+ years, we have watched political disagreements turn personal, workplace pressure follow people home, and misleading information shape big decisions. Here is the idea that ties the five parts together. When the institutions that are supposed to serve people stop doing so, people stop trusting those institutions. Then, little by little, they stop trusting each other. I cannot prove that chain link by link, and I will tell you when I am giving you my opinion instead of a fact. What I can do is show you the same pattern, documented by official investigators, at every level from a national government to a family dinner.

We start where the Constitution starts: with "We the People" and the governments created to serve them.


When the warning is on the desk


Hurricane Katrina hit the Gulf Coast in August 2005. A storm is nobody's fault, but the response is another matter. A special committee of the U.S. House spent five months on it and released a 520-page report that found failures at every level of government (Federal, State, Local). This was not a surprise. All three levels had already rehearsed a catastrophic hurricane striking New Orleans in a planning exercise, and they never finished acting on what it taught them. When the real storm came, forecasters gave 56 hours of solid warning. The order for everyone to leave New Orleans came just 19 hours before landfall. After the levees broke, it took almost a full day for that news to be confirmed to the President. The investigators said those failures cost lives, and that passivity did the most damage. They titled the report "A Failure of Initiative." People with authority had what they needed to act, and they waited.


The committee opened its report with an old riddle. Five frogs are sitting on a log, and four decide to jump off. How many are left? Five, because deciding to jump is not the same as jumping.


Katrina was not a one-time lapse. In Flint, Michigan, the state kept telling residents the water was safe when it was not, and a task force later called it "a story of government failure, intransigence, unpreparedness, delay, inaction, and environmental injustice." In London, seventy-two people died in the Grenfell Tower fire. The government had been "well aware of those risks," and residents who complained had been written off as troublemakers. Britain's government-owned Post Office wrongly convicted many hundreds of its own postmasters on the word of a faulty computer system. Australia sent unlawful debt letters to more than 500,000 people. The Dutch tax office wrongly labeled thousands of parents as fraudsters. Some of those families lost their homes, and the entire Dutch cabinet resigned over it. Official inquiries called the 2008 financial crisis avoidable, Fukushima "a profoundly manmade disaster," and Britain's Windrush scandal, in which lawful residents lost jobs and homes, "foreseeable and avoidable."


That makes nine failures in five countries, under governments of the left, the right, and coalitions in between.


When eight in ten of us ask and nothing happens


Ignoring a warning is one kind of neglect. Ignoring a request is another. On some questions, the American people have been asking for the same thing for years, in huge numbers and across party lines. Here are four. On each one, at least seven in ten of us agree, and on each one Washington has not delivered.


Proving who is voting. In October 2024, Gallup found that 84% of Americans favor requiring photo identification to vote, and 83% favor requiring proof of citizenship from people registering for the first time. Majorities of Republicans, independents, and Democrats all said yes. The SAVE America Act would require both. The House has passed a version of this idea three times since 2024, most recently in February 2026. In the Senate, where most bills need 60 votes out of 100 to move forward, it has been voted on and blocked, and as I write this it is still not law. Opponents say millions of citizens do not have a passport or birth certificate close at hand, and that voting by noncitizens is rare. Those points deserve a hearing. They do not explain why a request backed by more than eight in ten Americans has gone years without an answer.


Term limits for Congress. In 2023, Pew Research Center found that 87% of Americans favor limiting the number of terms members of Congress can serve. That included 90% of Republicans and 86% of Democrats. It is hard to find anything else that nine in ten of us agree on. Because of a 1995 Supreme Court ruling, term limits would probably take a constitutional amendment, and the people who would have to start that process are the same people the limits would apply to. They have not started it.


Stock trading by members of Congress. Members of Congress can buy and sell stock in companies their own votes affect. A 2023 University of Maryland survey found that 86% of Americans favor banning that, including more than eight in ten in each party. Leaders of both parties say they want a ban, and the President has said he would sign one. In July 2026 the House passed a bill, 232 to 198. In September it fell seven votes short in the Senate. The bill carried a voter ID provision that had nothing to do with stocks. Democrats objected to that, called the trading limits too weak, and voted no. Both parties say they are for a ban, and there is still no ban.


Money in campaigns. In that same 2023 Pew study, 72% of Americans said there should be limits on how much individuals and organizations can spend on political campaigns. Only 11% said there should be none. Democrats and Republicans were almost even, at 76% and 71%. The Supreme Court has ruled that much of this spending is protected speech, so lasting limits would likely take a constitutional amendment. Congress would have to propose one, and it has not.


I am not telling you how to feel about any of these. You may oppose one of them, or all four. My point is about leadership. When seven, eight, or nine out of ten of the people you serve keep asking for the same thing, a leader owes them one of two things: action, or an honest explanation, face to face, of why not. What we have been given is delay, procedure, and each party blaming the other.


What "we the people" learned


Put those two lists side by side. In the first, governments had the warning and waited. In the second, they have had the request for years and are still waiting. Underneath both I see the same three things, and this is my own reading. Someone knew. The people affected were not believed, or not heard. And admitting the truth took years and usually an outside investigation.


Now look at what people around the world say they learned from it. In late 2023 the OECD surveyed nearly 60,000 people in 30 countries. Only 39% had high or moderately high trust in their national government. Only 30% thought it likely that their political system lets people like them have a say.


Here is my opinion, after 38 years of leading people. Nobody in those nine stories needed a genius to prevent the harm. They needed Self-Awareness, the first pillar of my Human-Centered Leadership Blueprint™, to ask "what am I missing and who am I not hearing?" They needed Genuine Relationships, so that a complaint from a citizen landed as information instead of an attack. The same goes for a request that eight in ten citizens keep making.


When government stops asking "how will this affect the people we serve?", it teaches a lesson to everyone watching. The lesson is that the people at the top are not looking out for you. In Part 2, we will see how the biggest companies in the world taught that same lesson to their own customers.


  1. Hurricane Katrina - U.S. House select committee, A Failure of Initiative, 2006; NPR, Feb. 15; NPR, Feb. 13; report summary of findings, conclusion, and front matter

  2. Flint water crisis - Flint Water Advisory Task Force, 2016; AP via FOX 2; WTVR

  3. Grenfell Tower - Grenfell Tower Inquiry, Phase 2, 2024; The National; ASIS

  4. Post Office Horizon - Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry, Vol. 1, 2025; Report intro

  5. Robodebt - Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme, 2023; PM statement

  6. Dutch childcare benefits - Parliamentary report Unprecedented Injustice, 2020; AP via Sun-Times; DutchNews

  7. 2008 financial crisis - Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission, 2011; NPR

  8. Fukushima - National Diet of Japan independent commission, 2012; Executive summary

  9. Windrush - Windrush Lessons Learned Review, 2020; ITV

  10. Trust in government - OECD Trust Survey, 2024 results; OECD



 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Human-Centered Leadership vs Traditional Leadership

Human-centered leadership vs traditional leadership is a comparison of two ways to lead: one built on authority, control, and task management, the other on trust, genuine relationships, and people. Wi

 
 
bottom of page